Avoid These 5 Mistakes When Trying to Consolidate Debt

🔎 Disclosure: Heads up, babe: some links here are affiliate links, which means you might throw a tiny commission my way if you buy (zero extra cost to you). Only things you’d actually use and love get shared on this site.

1. Make Sure Debt Consolidation Is Right for You

Debt consolidation sounds great, but it’s not a magic fix for everyone.

You need to make sure your new loan actually saves you money. Do not add more to the problem.

Here’s how to double-check before jumping in:

  • Compare interest rates. The new rate should be clearly lower than what you’re paying now.
  • Check total repayment time. A longer loan might lower monthly payments but cost more overall.
  • Be honest about your habits. If you keep spending recklessly, no loan will help.
👉 Here's How You'll Do It: Use an online loan calculator to compare total costs and confirm consolidation will save you money long-term.

Make It Easy: Consider a financial planner notebook to track your current debts and interest rates side-by-side.


2. Avoid Using Credit Cards Again

Here’s the biggest mistake most people make after consolidating. They start using their credit cards again.

That’s like cleaning your kitchen just to spill spaghetti sauce all over the floor.

To stay out of debt for good:

  • Freeze your cards. Literally put them in a drawer or use a block app.
  • Switch to debit. Spend only what’s actually in your account.
  • Use cash for impulse zones. Groceries, gas, and coffee runs are easier to manage this way.
👉 Here's How You'll Do It: Leave your credit cards at home and commit to only using debit or cash for daily purchases.

Make It Easy: Consider a zippered cash envelope wallet to organize your weekly spending money.


3. Watch Out for Hidden Fees and High Rates

Debt consolidation can save you money. Or drain it quietly with sneaky fees.

Many loans come with setup charges, transfer fees, or penalties buried in fine print.

Before signing anything:

  • Read the agreement line by line. Never rush a financial contract.
  • Ask about fees. Application, origination, or early payoff fees are common traps.
  • Compare APR, not just interest. APR includes all costs, giving you the real total.
👉 Here's How You'll Do It: Ask your lender to break down every single fee in writing before you agree to the loan.

4. Stick to One Simple Payment Plan

Consolidation only works if you actually stick with it.

The goal is to replace five chaotic payments with one clean, consistent plan.

Here’s what helps you stay disciplined:

  • Automate your payment. Remove the “oops, I forgot” problem entirely.
  • Set reminders anyway. It’s satisfying to see the progress each month.
  • Track your balance decline. Seeing it drop motivates you to keep going.
👉 Here's How You'll Do It: Set up auto-pay for your consolidated loan so you never miss a payment again.

Make It Easy: Use Undebt.it to create and track your payment schedule with progress visuals.


5. Don’t Borrow More While Paying It Off

You can’t fill a bucket if there’s a hole in the bottom.

If you keep borrowing while trying to pay off debt, you’ll stay trapped in the same loop forever.

Here’s how to break the cycle:

  • Avoid new credit cards. They’ll tempt you into spending more.
  • Build a mini emergency fund. It stops you from relying on credit again.
  • Say no to unnecessary loans. Not every “deal” is worth the interest.
👉 Here's How You'll Do It: Create a rule for yourself. No new loans or credit cards until your consolidation is fully paid off.

📌 SAVE IT FOR LATER! 📌


Photo of author

Lily Thompson

Hey, I'm Lily! I'm a mom who's really good at two things: stretching a dollar and talking about stretching a dollar. I created Money Vice after one too many grocery trips where I watched my total climb and thought, "There's gotta be a better way." Spoiler: there is. Think of me as your money-savvy friend who's always got a tip (and coffee in hand).